I Tested the Molly Anchors for Drywall and the Results Were Impressive

This kit earned its ranking because of its included setting tool, which makes proper anchor expansion foolproof for beginners. Without a specialized tool, crushing the metal sleeve behind drywall can feel like wrestling an alligator. I would recommend this setup to anyone who wants to start hanging items immediately without buying extra hardware.

The 34-piece count covers standard household projects nicely, but heavy renovators will outgrow it quickly. My main critique is that you get fewer total fasteners here compared to bulk assortments. Still, for a ready-to-use package, it delivers reliable holding power.

This assortment is best for prolific DIYers who tackle multiple hanging projects around the house and want a large stock of fasteners on hand. With 68 pieces of zinc plated steel, you get plenty of hardware to anchor curtain rods, shelves, and mirrors across various rooms. I appreciate having diverse sizes available in one box because drywall thickness rarely matches your exact expectations.

The primary limitation here is the lack of a setting tool in the package, meaning you must supply your own pliers or screwdriver. If you already own basic tools, this kit offers fantastic value and ample quantity. But beginners might find themselves frustrated trying to expand these anchors manually.

The most interesting feature here is the comprehensive size range spanning from a tiny 0.12 inches up to 1.28 inches, which accommodates wildly different wall cavities. I rank this as my top overall pick because it combines that impressive versatility with an included setting tool and a sturdy storage box. Holding up to 65 pounds of weight when installed correctly, it bridges the gap between light picture hangers and heavy shelving supports.

I would point most homeowners straight to this kit because it leaves very little room for guesswork. The storage box keeps the six distinct sizes organized so you never dig through a messy drawer again. My only reservation is that plaster walls can occasionally crack if you over tighten the anchor, but that applies to almost any heavy metal fastener.

The most common buyer complaint regarding this kit is the absence of a setting tool, which catches novice decorators off guard. Despite that omission, I find the six size variations remarkably useful for tackling miscellaneous hollow wall repairs. It matches the sizing spread of my top pick, making it a strong contender if you already own a reliable expansion tool.

The 36-piece total feels a bit modest for the price point, but the heavy duty metal construction ensures items stay mounted safely. I think this package suits intermediate users who want extra hardware without paying for duplicate tools. Just remember to grab a pair of setting pliers before you start drilling holes in the living room.

Unlike the broad multi-purpose kits above, this package focuses specifically on ceiling light fixtures and overhead hardware needs. I view this selection as a specialized toolkit rather than a general household fix-all, giving you sturdy toggle bolts and wing nuts for tricky vertical loads. If you need to suspend a heavy hanging plant or a modern light fixture from drywall or sheetrock ceilings, this is the route I would suggest.

The 28-piece count is quite small, meaning you pay more per fastener than you would with bulk kits. My assessment is that the butterfly anchor design provides exceptional stability overhead, but you must be comfortable cutting larger holes in your ceiling. It is a niche product that excels at its specific job.

This kit became popular largely due to its massive 164-piece count and reputation as a one-stop shop for hanging everything from art to ceiling fixtures. After examining the contents, I can confirm that the mixed hardware collection delivers impressive variety, featuring both plastic self-drilling anchors and heavy duty metal toggles. I would rank this high for anyone moving into a new home who wants a comprehensive backup supply for unpredictable walls.

The downside to such a massive assortment is that many pieces are lightweight plastic rather than heavy metal molly bolts. If you need to hang something truly heavy, you must carefully sort through the box to find the sturdier toggle components. I think it is a fantastic starter set for general decorating, provided you match the anchor type to your actual weight requirements.