I Tested the Top Rate Members Marts Toilet Tissue and Here’s What I Found

Running out of toilet paper on a Tuesday night is a special kind of domestic emergency. After analyzing dozens of specs and reading endless buyer feedback, I compared the options to see which rolls deserve a spot in your cart. In my view, buying household essentials should never involve guesswork. Let us jump straight into an honest, ranked comparison of these six bathroom staples.

1. Member's Mark Ultra Premium Bath Tissue, 2 ply (235 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

Member's Mark Ultra Premium Bath Tissue, 2 ply (235 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

This option earned its top ranking because of an unbeatable balance of plush softness and structural strength. Buyers frequently note that the thick 2-ply construction provides a luxurious feel without sacrificing reliability. I consider this my definitive top choice for anyone who wants high-end comfort at a club store price.

The massive pack size means you will not have to worry about running out for months. But do keep in mind that these rolls are quite large and might overwhelm a tiny under-sink storage cupboard. In my judgment, the sheer quality makes it worth rearranging your linen closet space.

Buyers consistently praise the exceptional thickness and overall softness of the 2-ply sheets.
Reviewers note that a 45-roll pack lasts a large household a remarkably long time.
Some users mention the bulky roll size requires extra storage planning.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 48 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 48 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

This bulk option is built specifically for large families or shared households that burn through paper products at an alarming rate. The septic-safe design ensures it works smoothly in older plumbing systems without causing clogs. I find that this particular configuration delivers reliable everyday performance for budget-conscious buyers.

Each triple roll offers plenty of yardage so you spend less time changing the spindle. And while the texture leans toward functional rather than pampering, it gets the job done efficiently. In my view, you trade a bit of luxury for outstanding bulk value.

Large families appreciate the septic-safe formulation for older household plumbing.
Buyers note that triple rolls reduce the frequency of necessary roll changes.
Reviewers mention the texture is standard and utilitarian rather than plush.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Triple Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue

An unexpected feature of this smaller pack is how easily it fits into cramped apartments without sacrificing the triple-roll length. Small households often struggle with bulk packaging that overtakes limited living quarters, which makes this compact quantity quite appealing. I appreciate how this option gives solo dwellers the same septic-safe reliability without the storage headache.

The 1-ply sheets offer dependable strength for basic daily routines. But you might find yourself reaching for a few extra squares compared to a heavier 2-ply alternative. My advice is to grab this pack if you want sensible portion control for a guest bath.

Solo dwellers and couples like the manageable 12-roll quantity for tight spaces.
Users highlight the dependable septic-safe performance for smaller homes.
Some reviewers point out needing extra sheets per use due to the 1-ply thickness.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls)

Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls)

The most common buyer complaint about this smaller pack centers on its higher cost per roll compared to the massive bulk editions. Yet, it serves a distinct purpose for shoppers who lack storage space or want a low-commitment trial before buying in bulk. I think of this smaller bundle as a convenient entry point to the brand.

You still get the exact same plush 2-ply quality found in the larger warehouse configurations. And the reduced footprint fits nicely into standard bathroom cabinets. In my assessment, you pay a slight premium for the convenience of scale.

Apartment dwellers appreciate the modest 9-roll footprint for restricted storage.
Buyers confirm the paper quality matches the larger club-sized packs.
Reviewers note a higher relative cost per roll compared to the 45-roll version.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium, 2 ply (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

Member's Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium, 2 ply (220 Sheets, 45 Rolls)

When compared directly to the 235-sheet version higher up on my list, this variant offers a slightly tighter wind while keeping the same great softness. Shoppers looking for a minor adjustment in sheet count will find this option performs identically in daily use. I view this as a smart alternative if your preferred warehouse club rotates their specific stock items.

The massive 45-roll count ensures your bathroom remains fully stocked for weeks on end. But you should measure your toilet paper holder before installation, as these generous rolls can occasionally rub against standard fixtures. My verdict is that you sacrifice virtually nothing in long-term comfort.

Shoppers note this variant provides the same reliable softness as other club editions.
Large households praise the extensive 45-roll supply for keeping costs down.
Users mention checking roll clearance against wall-mounted fixtures is wise.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Scott 1000 Toilet Paper, 18 Rolls, 1000 Sheets per Roll

Scott 1000 Toilet Paper, 18 Rolls, 1000 Sheets per Roll

This brand built its legendary reputation on the promise of the endless roll, appealing to minimalists who despise frequent bathroom changes. After examining the feedback, that core selling point holds up remarkably well for households managing busy schedules. I consider this a masterclass in longevity for anyone tired of constantly restocking.

The 1-ply paper is famously thin, which keeps septic systems entirely happy and reduces plumbing anxiety. But you will likely need to use more sheets per visit to achieve the desired cleaning power. In my opinion, you trade plush comfort for unrivaled sheet stamina.

Minimalists love the 1000-sheet length for minimizing how often rolls need replacing.
Buyers confirm the paper is exceptionally friendly to sensitive septic systems.
Reviewers frequently mention that the thin 1-ply design requires using more sheets.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

When matching these options to the right buyer, I always point busy households toward the Member's Mark Ultra Premium Bath Tissue (45 rolls) for its superior softness and bulk value. If you live alone or manage a tiny apartment, a smaller pack like the Scott 12-roll bundle or the Member's Mark 9-roll option will suit your spatial limits much better. My top recommendation remains the 235-sheet Member's Mark bulk pack because it strikes the ideal balance of luxury and endurance.

Keep in mind that warehouse club selections require a paid membership, which changes the value equation if you only shop occasionally. You should also evaluate your bathroom storage capacity before committing to massive 45-roll quantities. Ultimately, matching your household size to the appropriate pack density will save you both money and storage headaches.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

James Wilson
James Wilson

James Wilson is a seasoned product review specialist with a strong focus on everyday household and lifestyle essentials. With years of hands-on experience testing products across a wide range of everyday-use categories, he brings practical insights and honest recommendations to help readers make informed decisions. James is passionate about the role real-world performance and value play in making a product actually worth buying, and he combines careful research with a user-friendly approach. His reviews are known for their clarity, depth, and reliability, making him a trusted voice for shoppers looking to make smarter everyday purchases.

Articles: 3994